This Loophole Could Cut Parent PLUS Loan Payments In Half

Heads up, mum or dad debtors: you’ll have extra choices to decrease your month-to-month student loan funds than you assume.

Parent PLUS loans — federal loans mother and father can take to cowl faculty prices for his or her undergraduate students — are one of many quickest rising segments of upper schooling debt. At the top of 2021, mother and father held $105 billion in PLUS loans, a 35% improve from 5 years earlier.

But these mum or dad loans may be dangerous as a result of they don’t include the identical borrowing limits student loans have. It’s attainable to borrow as much as the complete price of attendance, and oldsters typically discover the funds unaffordable, significantly as they’re approaching their remaining years within the labor market.

One motive why? Parents don’t have entry to the identical suite of inexpensive compensation plans out there to student debtors. That is, until they use a little-known loophole, referred to as double consolidation, that may assist them decrease their month-to-month funds.

We aren’t going to sugarcoat this: The double consolidation course of is difficult and it’s not a match for all mum or dad debtors. But for some, it could lower month-to-month funds by greater than half. Here’s the way it works.

What is double consolidation and what does it do?

Double consolidation is an unintended loophole in student loan laws that offers mother and father extra compensation choices tied to their earnings. The guidelines technically state that there’s just one income-driven compensation plan out there to mum or dad debtors, the Income-Contingent Repayment (ICR) plan, and oldsters can solely use it after they consolidate PLUS loans right into a Direct Consolidation Loan. That plan caps month-to-month funds at 20% of your “discretionary revenue“ and forgives the steadiness after 25 years of funds.

When you consolidate twice, nonetheless, you basically erase the truth that the unique loans have been mum or dad loans, and in doing so, you achieve entry to the income-driven plans for student debtors.

Those plans, referred to as Income-Based Repayment (IBR), Pay as You Earn (PAYE) and Revised Pay as You Earn (REPAYE), set funds based mostly on both 10% or 15% of your discretionary revenue, says Meagan Landress, an authorized student loan skilled with Student Loan Planner. The plans additionally outline discretionary revenue in a approach that shields extra of your earnings from the cost calculation. In different phrases, your month-to-month payments drop to 10% or 15% of your revenue and that proportion relies on a smaller portion of your take-home pay. Like with income-contingent compensation, the federal government forgives any steadiness remaining after a most of 25 years.

Double consolidation isn’t outlined on the federal web site, nor will your loan servicer recommend it. In reality, they may not learn about it. It’s not unlawful, although.

“There’s nothing you can get in trouble for,” Landress says, “but the one downside is Congress is aware this loophole exists. They could close access to the loophole by changing the legislation.”

Double consolidation advantages you by reducing your month-to-month cost considerably, says Fred Amrein, CEO of PayforEd, a student loan help firm. For instance, on the mum or dad income-contingent compensation plan, in case you had an adjusted gross revenue of $60,000, you’d owe $773.50 a month. But with the identical revenue on a extra beneficiant compensation plan that calculates funds based mostly on 10% of discretionary revenue, your month-to-month invoice would fall to about $330.

Who advantages most from the technique

Double consolidation is a fancy and time-consuming course of, and it isn’t appropriate for a lot of debtors. Any time you consolidate, for instance, it restarts the clock in your cost credit. That means in case you’ve already been making funds for a number of years and dealing towards forgiveness after 25 years on the income-contingent plan, double consolidation would possibly decrease your month-to-month funds, however it will imply you’d need to pay for a lot of extra years, since you would be beginning over in your timeline to forgiveness.

However, in case you’re carrying a loan steadiness higher than your revenue, it could present important aid, says Erik Kroll, a monetary planner who incessantly works with purchasers who’re over 50 and paying down student debt.

Depending in your age, 25 years might imply you’re making loan funds deep into retirement, however when you have substantial debt, that could be the one manageable path. Keep in thoughts that federal loans are discharged if you find yourself disabled otherwise you die earlier than they’re paid off. It’s a miserable thought, however a minimum of nobody inherits the debt. (However, simply because the debt is discharged while you die doesn’t imply you’ll be able to cease paying in retirement. If you fall behind and default in your loans, the federal government can garnish your Social Security funds and seize tax refunds).

Alongside double consolidation, monetary advisors additionally recommend contributing as a lot as you’ll be able to into certified retirement accounts to cut back taxable revenue. That kills two birds: you’ll have a decrease loan cost based mostly on the diminished taxable revenue and also you’ll improve your retirement financial savings.

Loan funds could drop even decrease when you’re absolutely retired in case you’re dwelling off a decrease taxable retirement revenue.

“You have a little control over how much you take from your retirement accounts, which dictates your income, which dictates your payment,” Kroll says.

The nitty gritty on the steps concerned in double consolidation

The technique is named double consolidation, however you’re truly consolidating 3 times with three totally different servicers (two of them concurrently). That’s why it takes time. According to the federal authorities, consolidation takes 30-90 days, although Landress has seen 30-45 days.

Typically, you received’t begin the method till after you’ve completed borrowing on your student — that may very well be 4 or extra years after the primary loan — and it’s usually greatest to go away your personal schooling loans out of the method since you don’t need to restart the clock on these loans in the event that they’re already in one of many income-driven plans.

Landress has written a really detailed article on double consolidation, however right here’s an outline.

First consolidation

You’ll want a minimum of two particular person PLUS loans, although most individuals who borrow take out a brand new loan for annually they borrow, so this shouldn’t be a difficulty. As a primary step, you’ll submit two paper purposes to 2 loan servicers totally different out of your present servicers. You’ll request to consolidate a portion of your PLUS loans right into a Direct Consolidation Loan with every one. You can consolidate any mixture, even one loan with one servicer and three with one other. Think of it as “converting” your loans, relatively than simply consolidating a number of loans right into a single one, Landress says. Each servicer consolidates the loans submitted. They received’t know you’re additionally consolidating with one other servicer. The paper purposes make sure the loans aren’t mixed into one Direct Consolidation loan, as would occur in case you utilized on-line. At the top, you might have two Direct Consolidation loans. This course of might take as much as 90 days.

Second consolidation

Now it’s time to use on-line to a 3rd servicer to mix the 2 consolidation loans. It’s this third servicer course of that opens up entry to the opposite income-driven plans, as a result of the Parent PLUS tag is now lengthy gone. The whole course of from starting to finish might take a minimum of 6 months.

Why you would possibly want a monetary skilled

Even in any case that work, you continue to could have some difficult inquiries to kind via, together with which income-driven plan makes probably the most monetary sense on your circumstances. For instance, Pay as You Earn (PAYE) and Revised Pay as You Earn (REPAYE) are probably the most inexpensive, basing your cost on 10% of your revenue, however REPAYE counts spousal revenue within the cost calculation, whereas PAYE has stricter eligibility parameters. Married folks could profit extra from the Pay as Your Earn and Income-Based Repayment plans, as a result of these plans calculate cost off a single revenue. But that additionally means submitting taxes as married, submitting individually to qualify. Experts sometimes suggest altering your tax submitting standing the 12 months earlier than in preparation for consolidating.

Finding the proper recommendation isn’t at all times straightforward.

“Loan servicers and financial aid officers cannot provide any tax or personal finance advice, and tax professionals don’t understand student loan payment,” Amrein says.

That’s why a monetary advisor with a Certified Student Loan Planner designation and a tax background could also be value consulting. Check the Certified Student Loan Advisors Institute for somebody in your space. This particular person may assist you to assess whether or not leaping via the hoops to finish a double consolidation is well worth the work on your private circumstances.

“You’ll have to understand the numbers,” Amrein says.

More from Money:

Parents Can Qualify for Student Loan Forgiveness, Too. Here’s How

Why Hasn’t Joe Biden Forgiven All Your Student Loan Debt? Short Answer: He Never Promised To

6 Best Student Loans of 2022