Student debt: Is loan forgiveness the answer?

Student debt: Is loan forgiveness the reply?

Watch the CBSN Originals documentary “The Student Debt Dilemma” within the video participant above. It premieres on CBSN Sunday, March 28, at 8 p.m., 11 p.m. and a couple of a.m. ET.


By 2015, Lauren Quinn had borrowed $49,996 in federal student loans to pursue a grasp’s diploma in training at UCLA. But after virtually 5 years of constructing month-to-month repayments tied to her revenue degree, she is confronted with a complete steadiness of $56,497.02 — about $6,500 greater than the unique quantity as a result of compounding curiosity. 

“It’s just another day older, deeper in debt is how I feel,” stated Quinn, a public highschool trainer in Los Angeles. “It just feels like quicksand. It feels like this huge thing I’ll never get out from under.” 

She has paid a complete of $9,621.96 since 2016, however solely $97.02 of that has been utilized to her principal steadiness. 

lauren-teaching-students.jpg
High college trainer Lauren Quinn owes greater than $50,000 after getting a grasp’s diploma in training.

CBS News


Quinn is among the many 42.9 million Americans who had federal student loans as of final 12 months, in keeping with the National Student Loan Data System. Meanwhile, Federal Reserve Board statistics present excellent student loans total have swelled to $1.7 trillion, surpassing the nation’s auto loans and credit card debt. 

Seth Frotman, government director of the non-profit advocacy group Student Borrower Protection Center, characterised the present state of student loans as a “quiet crisis.” 

“Maybe unlike the mortgage crisis where you could see down the street there used to be a house owned by your neighbor that’s now owned by the bank, there isn’t this visual, tangible thing you could see when your neighbor defaults on a loan or your neighbor’s struggling to save for retirement because their student loan bill just never seems to go away. And I think that has also hampered our ability as a country to actually tackle both the root causes of this crisis and the fallout it’s had on American families,” Frotman stated. 

The fallout for Jeremy Porter has been the delay in buying a house and probably rising his household. 

“I feel that the student loan debt, my student loan debt, personally is very crippling,” Porter stated. 

jeremy.jpg
Jeremy Porter stated he worries about with the ability to afford a home and children as a result of burden of student loan debt.

CBS News


Porter initially took out $21,900 in federal student loans to attend Delta State University in Mississippi. But now over seven years later, his whole steadiness has grown to $30,443.93. He didn’t full his undergraduate program, however by means of the nationwide workforce improvement program Year Up, Porter was capable of join with an internship in Virginia and finally stand up the ranks to grow to be a senior telecommunications officer on the identical firm. 

“A lot of times I’ve had to defer just because it’s either make these payments or pay my rent. And of course you have to have a roof over your head,” Porter stated. 

The push to forgive student debt

Democratic lawmakers together with Senator Chuck Schumer, Senator Elizabeth Warren and Representative Ayanna Pressley, amongst others, have known as on President Biden to forgive $50,000 in federal student loans by government motion, citing analysis displaying such cancellation would assist shut the racial wealth hole and stimulate the financial system, particularly throughout the COVID-19 pandemic. Mr. Biden has indicated he favors a $10,000 debt cancellation by means of laws.

Princeton sociology professor Frederick Wherry and Charlie Eaton, an assistant professor of sociology at UC Merced, helped draft an open letter asking Mr. Biden to “right a series of wrongs” through the use of government motion to cancel student debt. More than 1,100 different teachers who examine increased training, student debt, and racial inequality signed on. 

“Part of this is just recognizing the humanity of debtors, recognizing that they had ambitions when they took out those debts to go to college, and asking ourselves what would happen if they got a fresh start,” stated Wherry, who can be the director of the Dignity and Debt Network. 

“If we want to right the wrongs of the student loan problem… one of the ways to right that wrong is to say, ‘Sorry, we messed up,'” Wherry stated. “This would be a moment for the federal government, President Biden, to say, ‘We had a great idea. It started out with the best of intentions, and it went off the rails. So because we messed up, it is time for us not only to ask for forgiveness, but to extend forgiveness.”‘

Despite a lower in annual borrowing total within the final decade, excellent student loan debt has greater than doubled to $1.7 trillion over the identical interval. 

Eaton, whose upcoming guide “Bankers in the Ivory Tower” explores the affect of financiers in increased training, stated, “I think it’s fair to ask the question, do we really want the secretary of education to be effectively the CEO of the largest consumer bank in America?”

Racial disparities and student debt: A “two worlds issue” 

Wherry additionally confused the disproportionate methods the student loan system burdens Black communities specifically, calling it a “two worlds issue.” 

According to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and 2011-12 knowledge from the U.S. Department of Education, over 90% of Black undergraduate students go away school with student debt, in comparison with 66% of White students. 

“Having grown up in South Carolina, the one thing that I would hear over and over again as a young Black kid was, ‘Get your education. It’s the one thing they can’t take from you.’ So you were supposed to do whatever it took, and the family was willing to do whatever it would take in order for you to get your education, which required debt,” Wherry stated. 

frederick.jpg
Princeton sociology professor Frederick Wherry says America must “right the wrongs of the student loan problem.”

CBS News


According to a 2016 Brookings report, Black students owed about $7,400 extra on common than White students upon commencement, however the debt hole greater than triples to $25,000 after 4 years. Black debtors are additionally extra prone to default, and they’re extra prone to enroll in for-profit establishments for graduate college diploma packages. 

Frotman stated the business “targets” debtors of coloration. 

“We’ve seen cases about how for-profit schools engage in [reverse] redlining practices, particularly offering worthless degrees into the hardest-hit communities. We see how student loan servicers will fail to get borrowers of color into critical consumer protections, leaning them more prone to delinquency and default. This happens over and over again where it’s not only more debt, it’s how the student loan industry drives needless interest, fees, predatory products that just makes the student debt crisis even worse,” he stated. 

Rising value of training 

Among the elements contributing to the expansion in student loan debt is the surging price ticket of upper training. Between 2007 and 2017, the price of undergraduate training at public establishments (together with tuition, charges, room and board) rose by 31%, adjusting for inflation, in keeping with the Department of Education. At personal nonprofit establishments, costs rose by 23%. 

“The one thing that [colleges] could count on was the fact that the demand for education was not going to go away. So long as the federal government’s backing those loans and you’ve got this really robust market to provide those loans, whatever your expenses are or what they are, the students will still come,” Wherry stated. “That is exactly what happened, and they have come into situations where there are some beautiful dorm rooms now across all these colleges, great athletic facilities, etc., but at a very high cost.”

On high of the rising costs, if student debt cancellation had been to grow to be a further issue, economist Beth Akers of the conservative think-tank American Enterprise Institute stated she could be involved. Students could also be inclined to borrow extra or go to a costlier establishment as a result of chance that loans is perhaps forgiven sooner or later, she stated. 

“We take discipline off of individuals to make good decisions about their finances. And then the result of that is that we get institutions lacking the pressure from their student borrowers to keep prices in line with value,” Akers stated. 

The value of forgiveness

Some critics of cancellation proposals level out that student debt forgiveness packages at the moment exist inside the federal monetary help system. 

“It’s a solution that ignores the solution that’s already in place,” Akers stated. She pointed to income-driven reimbursement plans, which forgive remaining balances after 20 to 25 years of qualifying month-to-month funds, and the Public Service Loan Forgiveness program that forgives after 10 years of qualifying funds. But Akers acknowledged they’re applied “very poorly,” and are not out there to all debtors. 

beth.jpg
Economist Beth Akers of the American Enterprise Institute says widespread cancellation would provide “a lot of benefits to people who are already doing quite well in this economy.”

CBS News


Recent knowledge obtained by the National Consumer Law Center confirmed solely 32 people have really acquired loan forgiveness because the launch of the primary income-driven reimbursement plan in 1995. The coverage and advocacy group estimates that roughly 2 million debtors have been in reimbursement for no less than 20 years below the varied income-driven reimbursement plans.

Akers additionally argues that widespread cancellation would provide “a lot of benefits to people who are already doing quite well in this economy.”

Brookings evaluation of Federal Reserve knowledge confirmed households with grasp’s, skilled or doctoral levels owe 56% of the nation’s student debt. Their median family earnings are roughly $72,000, $111,000 and $101,000, respectively, in keeping with 2019 U.S. Census Bureau knowledge. 

Additionally, critics like Alexander Holt, a coverage analyst on the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, make the case that blanket cancellation of student debt would current a “moral hazard” and is “not a good use of taxpayer dollars.” 

“There’s a cost to forgiveness. It depends on the cancellation policy being proposed, but it’s either hundreds of billions of dollars or up to a trillion dollars,” Holt stated. “That cost adds to the federal debt. So ultimately, taxpayers are responsible for the federal debt.”

He added, “If we were to cancel student loans, we are basically making a decision to provide relief now and have some future generation pay for it later. That’s particularly egregious since we’re also saying we’re not going to change any parameters of the student loan system.”

Holt stated lawmakers needs to be contemplating insurance policies that “help people at the lower end of the income spectrum, especially now” throughout the pandemic. “Those tend to be the people who didn’t go to college, who didn’t take out any debt,” Holt stated, they usually make up a majority of the U.S. inhabitants. Statistics from the U.S. Census Bureau present 64% of individuals over the age of 25 wouldn’t have a bachelor’s diploma or increased. 

“No silver bullet” 

While funds of federal student loans are at the moment suspended as a result of COVID-19 emergency aid measures, and the rate of interest is at 0% till no less than September 30, 2021, excellent student debt nonetheless looms over about 1 in 8 Americans.

“There’s no silver bullet for a $1.7 trillion crisis,” Frotman stated, including that the problem must be tackled “from all angles.” 

“We need to enhance the consumer protections, so student loan borrowers are no longer second-class citizens being forced to deal with abuses that people with a mortgage or credit card don’t have to face,” Frotman stated. “We need to improve the Department of Education to ensure that they’re actually doing a much better job overseeing these programs. We have to make college more affordable for the next generation, so we’re not just dealing with this in another five years. On the table needs to be reducing, canceling debt for millions of people across this country who have been held back because of it.” 

In an announcement, the Department of Education instructed CBSN Originals: 

“To strengthen this country and our global competitiveness, we must ensure that students can enroll and graduate from college without the fear of lifelong debt all students deserve access to a high-quality, affordable education that equips them with the skills to succeed. To fulfill that goal, the Department of Education must act to protect students from institutions that take advantage of their postsecondary investments — particularly when it is financed with federal financial aid. The same goes with the companies that service or hold federal student loans. Borrowers deserve world-class service that makes it easier for them to manage their benefits. When they do not, there must be consequences. The fact that students of color are disproportionately likely to have student loans or have attended colleges with credible accusations of misconduct further highlights the importance of strong protection. 

“We have taken the primary steps to uphold these guarantees when the Department introduced a change that can grant some 72,000 debtors a recent begin after their faculties engaged in misconduct. That is only one step. This work will proceed because the Biden-Harris Administration is dedicated to offering alternatives to all students.” 

READ:   Court Allows Bankruptcy Discharge Of $200,000 In Student Loans

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *