3 takeaways from NPR's investigation into a troubled student loan repayment program

3 takeaways from NPR’s investigation right into a troubled student loan reimbursement program

An NPR investigation has discovered {that a} federal program supposed to assist low-income student loan debtors, and finally supply them debt cancellation, has did not reside as much as its promise.

More than 9 million debtors are at the moment enrolled in income-driven reimbursement (IDR) plans, that are designed to assist individuals who can’t afford to make giant month-to-month funds. The plans promise loan cancellation after 20-25 years. But paperwork obtained by NPR supply putting proof that these plans have been badly mismanaged by loan servicers and the U.S. Department of Education.

In all, these information paint a panoramic image of IDR’s failure, and solid a shadow over the federal student loan program. While the Biden administration didn’t make these issues, it should now handle them because it weighs restarting reimbursement after a two-year pandemic pause.

In response to NPR’s request for remark, an Education Department spokesperson stated on Friday, “Borrowers place their trust in us to make sure these plans work the way they were intended to, and we intend to honor that trust. We are aware of historical issues with prior processes that had undermined accurate tracking of eligible payments. The current situation is unacceptable and we are committed to addressing those issues.”

Here are three takeaways from NPR’s investigation, which you’ll learn in its entirety right here:

1. Some servicers had no thought when debtors certified for forgiveness.

IDR plans supply debtors a manageable month-to-month fee (as little as $0) in addition to loan cancellation after 20-25 years of qualifying funds. It’s the servicer’s job to depend what number of funds a borrower has made after which notify them after they qualify for loan cancellation.

READ:   How Do I Refinance My Student Loans?

But a beforehand unreleased 2016 evaluation of servicers, performed by the Education Department’s workplace of Federal Student Aid, discovered that three servicers – PHEAA, CornerStone and MOHELA – did “not have an IDR forgiveness payment counter” to trace debtors’ progress towards cancellation.

Borrowers with accounts at PHEAA, for instance, would have needed to request a guide depend of previous funds to gauge their eligibility for cancellation.

This means some servicers did not know if debtors certified for cancellation except they have been requested, by debtors, to do a labor-intensive information evaluation.

2. Mismanagement of IDR is very dangerous for debtors with the bottom incomes.

Under IDR, a month-to-month fee of $0 for a borrower incomes lower than 150% of the federal poverty line ought to nonetheless depend towards loan cancellation. But in the identical 2016 evaluation, officers warned, “zero ($0.00) IDR payments that qualify for forgiveness are not adequately tracked.”

Nearly half of all IDR debtors are making $0 month-to-month funds, in line with a 2019 evaluation by the Center for American Progress (CAP). Not adequately monitoring these funds may delay or derail tens of millions of the lowest-income debtors on their technique to loan cancellation.

3. Transferring debtors between servicers is a sport of phone.

According to the paperwork obtained by NPR, shifting borrower accounts is extremely fraught. Borrowers’ info is transferred through what’s often called an EA27 file, and each time a file is transferred, information and context may be misplaced, and errors made. In truth, earlier variations of the EA27 did not even embody fee counts for sure IDR plans.

READ:   Email deal with for contacting student loans firm - a Freedom of Information request to Student Loans Company Limited

Now contemplate that just about each borrower who may be eligible for cancellation underneath IDR within the subsequent few years has had their accounts transferred no less than as soon as, when the federal authorities transitioned from one loan servicer to many. That means their present information, together with the depend of their progress towards cancellation, could possibly be constructed on the sand of faulty information.


NPR is dedicated to reporting on urgent points that matter to you, like student loans. Sign up for our Education publication to remain updated. You can help NPR’s trusted, important protection by donating to your native NPR station immediately.

Copyright 2022 NPR. To see extra, go to https://www.npr.org.